Review: Battle of the Benriach 22 Single Casks! (Rum and Port)

Benriach 22 Cadenhead’s Rum Cask 1992

Appearance: 0.2, Pale Straw

Nose: Rich barley sugar and cereal notes, some licorice, menthol, under-ripe pears. A bit flat in terms of depth and body.

Taste: Quite malty and grainy, there is definitely a note of bitter molasses, hint of ash, orange blossom honey, vanilla and icing sugar, very faint spearmint note.

Finish: Somewhat thin, the ash comes out again, some malty sweetness. Pretty flat and short.

Notes: This whisky strikes me as an example of where a cask finish was used to try to paint over a poor initial maturation. The profile is lacking in complexity and body, and I don’t think the rum cask did much to save it. It seems to have added a bit of a bitter molasses and ash note, which doesn’t bolster it like a heavy wine cask finish would. This definitely does not taste like a 22 year old whisky; more like a 12-14 year old. Overall, this is a miss for me sadly.

Score: 82/100

Benriach Single Cask, 1992, 22 Years, Cask 976, Tawny Port Finish

Appearance: 1.5, Auburn

Nose: Big time chocolate and coffee, cherries and dates, cappuccino ice cream, dunnage and slightly damp old wood, menthol.

Taste: Red plums, barley sugar, honey, cherry cough syrup, very thick and weighty on the palate, hints of mint chocolate ice cream, espresso coffee cake, chocolate covered coffee beans, and rum.

Finish: A bit tart, menthol, red fruits and golden syrup, mocha. Long.

Notes: Now this is what I’m talking about. This has the typical heavy notes from a red wine finished whisky, but with some really interesting coffee/mint elements that add a neat accent (and also provide some uniqueness). The base spirit is also very weighty which helps the whisky not be overwhelmed by the cask influence. Really beefy and complex, but balanced and refined.

Score: 91/100

2 thoughts on “Review: Battle of the Benriach 22 Single Casks! (Rum and Port)

  1. Wow! At least on paper, this doesn’t sound like a battle of bottles, but a clash of titans! I would have expected the Cadenhead’s bottling to get a better score, though. I got a 24 years old Dalmore with a rum cask finish from them and that one’s really great!

    Like

    1. Yeah this was definitely a mismatch; one whisky punching way below it’s weight category; the colour difference sort of betrays this too. Given the diversity of rums, from lighter to super dark, it could also have a big difference which particular rum distillery the cask was from, so that could also be a factor. Ultimately, I just think the original cask used was under active or 3rd refill. Thanks for reading!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s